| Platinum | Russo's New York Pizzeria |
| Gold | Industrial Pizza + Brew |
| Silver | Olive Oil's Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Partenope Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Besa's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Marco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Milano Pizza |
| Top Pick | Roccos Italian Cafe |
| Top Pick | SPIN! Pizza |
| Top Pick | The Pizza Dude |