| Platinum | Fish Shack |
| Gold | Coco Shrimp |
| Silver | Silver Fox Steakhouse |
| Bronze | Anayas Seafood Scratch Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Fish City Grill - Lake Highlands |
| Top Pick | Fish N' Tails Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Sushi Rock |
| Top Pick | Tasty Tails |
| Top Pick | Tricky Fish |
| Top Pick | Urban Seafood Company |