| Platinum | Fish Shack |
| Platinum | Tongue in Cheek Ice Cream |
| Gold | Lockwood Distilling Co |
| Silver | Chocolate Angel Cafe & Tea Room |
| Bronze | Frankie's Mexican Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Anayas Seafood Scratch Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Cafe Brazil |
| Top Pick | Industrial Pizza + Brew |
| Top Pick | Russo's New York Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | SPIN! Pizza |