| Platinum | Haystack Burgers & Barley |
| Gold | Del's Charcoal Burgers |
| Silver | Shady's Burgers & Brewhaha |
| Bronze | Olive Burger |
| Top Pick | Hat Creek Burger Company |
| Top Pick | LA Burger |
| Top Pick | Liberty Burger |
| Top Pick | Smashburger |
| Top Pick | Sonic Drive-In |
| Top Pick | Twisted Root Burger |